Previous studies commissioned by the EU have shown that the EU has been leading the world in imports of ‘embodied deforestation’ in the form of agricultural and timber products. This study goes a...
Mahogany market in US threatening the lives of uncontacted natives in the Amazon
Consumers in the US purchasing mahogany furniture may be unwittingly supporting illegal logging in a Peruvian reserve for uncontacted indigenous tribes, imperiling the indigenous peoples' lives. A new report by the Upper Amazon Conservancy (UAC) provides evidence that loggers are illegally felling mahogany trees in the Murunahua Reserve where it is estimated some 200 uncontacted natives live.
"It would be a tragedy for US citizens to continue buying Peruvian mahogany if it puts the survival of uncontacted Indians at risk," said Stephen Corry, director of Survival International, an indigenous rights organization, in a press release
According to the report, over 80 percent of mahogany exports from Peru end up in the US, making it very likely that illegally logged wood is entering the US market. In 2008 the US passed an amendment to the Lacey Act which outlaws the importation, possession, or sale of illegally sourced wood; however the UAC has found evidence that Peruvian illegal loggers are circumventing the law.
"They use forestry permits allocated for timber concessions or titled indigenous land, when really the wood has come from somewhere else," David Hill, also of Survival International, told mongabay.com. "In other words, it is the very system designed to legalize the trade that is exploited for the illegal trade. An appalling irony."
While oil and gas companies have recently been barred from the reserve due to fears for the natives' safety, the UAC report alleges that logging is 'widespread' in the protected area, including logging roads and vehicles that bring the wood to a nearby river for transport.
Illegal loggers threaten uncontacted natives by more ways than cutting down the forest on which they depend: the illegal loggers spread disease. Uncontacted natives are especially vulnerable to disease due to a lack of natural defenses against illnesses they have not yet encountered. When some Muruhanua indigenous groups were first contacted in the 1990s—also by illegal loggers—populations were decimated: half the contacted natives perished from disease and violence.
"The only ways to stop this happening is for US buyers to reject any Peruvian mahogany, or the US government to ban exports temporarily. Until that happens, people in the US have no idea where the wood they're buying is actually coming from," says Hill.
To date Peru has turned a blind eye to logging in the reserve, yet Hill argues that it wouldn't be difficult to put a halt to the illegal trade.
"Peru's government needs to find the necessary political will and allocate the necessary resources to stop loggers entering uncontacted tribes' land. What that means in practice is building control posts along the rivers, with all the requisite technical and financial support to permit them to do their job effectively," says Hill. "The areas we're talking about are very remote and there aren't that many ways of gaining access: in other words, it's a question of identifying which rivers the loggers use and then stopping them entering. It's not rocket science."
Assessing illegal logging
Chatham House is assessing the scale and effectiveness of the response to illegal logging and the related trade around the world. Full details of this work, including analysis and data, will be available online soon.